Why bushs resort to military tribunals rests on a bad. The decision of this question does not depend on argument or judicial precedents, numerous and highly illustrative as they are davis p. Lawyers for the accused, who included lauson stone and kenneth royall, attempted to have the case tried in a civilian court but were rebuffed by the united states supreme court in ex parte quirin, 317 u. The supreme court distinguished between lawful combatants uniformed soldiers and unlawful. This article was first published in the summer 2005 edition of the warrior, the journal of gerry spences trial lawyers college. Jan 09, 2012 ex parte quirin upheld the jurisdiction of a united states military tribunal over the trial of several operation pastorius saboteurs in the united states. This article argues that the issue of enemy combatant detentions should be studied through the lens of the treason clause of article iii. In the course of deciding quirin, the supreme court rejected the precedent of ex parte milligan, on which the nazi saboteurs had relied the high courts landmark ruling in ex parte milligan was issue in 1866, following the civil war.
Following the declaration of war between the united states and germany, eight german residents, richard quirin, ernst burger, george dasch, herbert haupt, heinrich heinck, edward keiling, herman neubauer, and werener thiel, received training on sabotage at a school near berlin. My point is that the ex parte quirin case establishes that us citizenship in and of itself does not provide immunity against military justice. The courts fateful turn in ex parte quirin, the nazi saboteur case. Antiterrorism and due process oxford university press. Cheneys distinction between unlawful combatants and prisoners of war relies on ex parte quirin. Unlawful combatants are likewise subject to capture and detention, but in addition they are subject to trial and punishment by military tribunals for. A leading precedent ripe for reconsideration is ex parte quirin, a world war iiera case in which the supreme court held that saboteurs admittedly employed by an enemy nations military had a right to access civilian courts during wartime to challenge their trial before a. The court will not set aside acts ordered by the president concerning acts of war, as that power is invested to the president under the constitution facts. If, in light of the jurisprudence based on the ex parte quirin decision, one can conclude that it is the very nature of the acts that makes the person an enemy combatant, in the context of the mca, one must conclude that it is their political character that designates the person committing such acts as an enemy combatant. The decision in ex parte quirin has been used by the george w. Mainstream use of the term unlawful combatant originated in 1942 with the us supreme court case of ex parte quirin. Professor kent will be guestposting about the article, so the readings post will be brief, but we wanted to flag this interesting and provocative analysis of ex parte quirin.
Ex parte quirinopinion of the court wikisource, the. Understanding enemy combatant status and the military commissions act, part i. In the case of a civil war or an insurrection state may be replaced by the more general term party to the. Dec 20, 2012 a leading precedent ripe for reconsideration is ex parte quirin, a world war iiera case in which the supreme court held that saboteurs admittedly employed by an enemy nations military had a right to access civilian courts during wartime to challenge their trial before a military commission. Supreme court case concerned eight german saboteurs captured after their infiltration into the united states, where they planned to attack war industries and weaken americas ability to mobilize its forces to fight in europe. Ex parte quirin wikisource, the free online library. A leading precedent ripe for reconsideration is ex parte quirin, a world war iiera case in which the supreme court held that saboteurs admittedly employed by an enemy nations military had a right to access civilian courts during wartime to challenge their trial before a military commission. An ex parte judicial proceeding is conducted for the benefit of.
Following the declaration of war between the united states and germany, eight german residents, richard quirin, ernst burger, george dasch, herbert haupt, heinrich heinck, edward keiling, herman neubauer, and werener thiel, received training on. The habeas privilege and enemy combatants j a m e s e. Professor kent will be guestposting about the article, so the readings post will be brief, but we wanted to flag this interesting and provocative analysis. Understanding enemy combatant status and the military. Bush 2008 extending habeas protection to aliens detained as enemy combatants at guantanamo bay. Fisher also takes issue with the bush administrations mistaken citing of ex parte quirin as an apt precedent for trying suspected al qaeda terrorists. The spy who secretly and without uniform passes the military lines of a belligerent in time of war, seeking to gather military information and communicate it to the enemy, or an enemy combatant who without uniform comes secretly through the lines for the purpose of waging war by destruction of life or property, are familiar examples of. By the law of war, lawful combatants are subject to capture and detention as prisoners of war. The government placed principal reliance on the socalled nazi saboteur case, ex parte quiring there, the supreme court rejected statutory and constitutional challenges to the trial by military commission of german. Mar 01, 2007 mainstream use of the term unlawful combatant originated in 1942 with the us supreme court case of ex parte quirin. This phrase, unlawful combatant, appears all over the place as though it could be the talisman that saves bushs tribunals. A postcivil war decision against military tribunals.
Ex parte quirinopinion of the court wikisource, the free. The forgotten constitutional law of treason and the enemy. Enemy combatant us extraterritorial detainees wiki fandom. This article serves as a short summary of my research and analysis of enemy combatant status as it is being used in the socalled war on terrorism. In the 1942 supreme court of the united states ruling ex parte quirin, the court uses the terms with their historical meanings to distinguish between unlawful combatants and lawful combatants. Oct 04, 2010 ex parte quirin does not stand for the proposition that the president is entitled to order the extrajudicial killing of an american citizen or anything of the sort. Furthermore, the court asserted that the fifth and sixth amendments did not enlarge the right to jury trial beyond those cases where it was. The analysis in the following paper was written by stewart rhodes while at yale law school and was the winner of yales judge william e. The nazi saboteur case and the tribunal precedent, in national security law brief, vol. In the case of a civil war or an insurrection state may be replaced by the more general term party to the conflict as described in the 1949 geneva. Oct 07, 2010 my point is that the ex parte quirin case establishes that us citizenship in and of itself does not provide immunity against military justice when you are in an enemy fighting force. Fisher also takes issue with the bush administrations mistaken citing of ex parte quirin as an apt precedent for. Milligan had been convicted by a military commission of violating the laws of war by. Ex parte quirin case brief for law students casebriefs.
Citizens suirin associate themselves with the military arm of the enemy government, and, with its aid. Jul 01, 2011 the spy who secretly and without uniform passes the military lines of a belligerent in time of war, seeking to gather military information and communicate it to the enemy, or an enemy combatant who without uniform comes secretly through the lines for the purpose of waging war by destruction of life or property, are familiar examples of. The supreme court first used the term in 1942 in ex parte quirin to solve a particular problem that arose when eight german spies landed in civilian clothes on the beaches of long island. These cases concern operation pastorius, a failed attempt in june 1942 by nazi agents to sabotage various u. Jan 28, 20 a leading precedent ripe for reconsideration is ex parte quirin, a world war iiera case in which the supreme court held that saboteurs admittedly employed by an enemy nations military had a right to access civilian courts during wartime to challenge their trial before a military commission. Tyler writes exceptionally well, with a talent for gripping narration and telling detail. Usually enemy combatants are members of the armed forces of the state with which another state is at war. Enemy combatant wikimili, the best wikipedia reader. In the case of a civil war or an insurrection the term enemy state may be replaced by the more general term party to the conflict. I asked andrew to write up this piece, after reading an earlier draft of the underlying paper for a workshop last summer that matt and trevor organized at columbia law school. Judicial notebookjudicial deference in times of crisis.
Enemy combatant, extraordinary legal status developed by the administration of pres. Thus, the fbis bogus claim to have nabbed the saboteurs entirely on their own was allowed to stand, while the saboteurs death sentences were initially kept hidden from public view. Andrew kent writes in with the following guest post on his fascinating new article on ex parte quirin. The privilege of citizenship, the court held, entitles hamdi to.
Enemy combatant is a term historically referring to members of the armed forces of the state with which another state is at war. Pdf enemy combatant download full pdf book download. Ex parte quirin upheld the jurisdiction of a united states military tribunal over the trial of several operation pastorius saboteurs in the united states. Quirin has been cited as a precedent for the trial by military commission of any unlawful combatant against the. Legal scholar seemed to agree that the administration could designate people, even u. Specifically, the article argues that the treason clause prohibits the exercise of military authority over individuals who are subject to the law of treason, a category that includes not only united states citizens, but almost all persons merely present. The problems raised by royall regarding a court that had its judge, jury, and counsel appointed by the president are pertinent to trials. I found both the history andrew had dug up to be completely eyeopening, and the analysis to be. But it does stand for the idea that in wartime the fact that an enemy combatant holds a u. Any person in an armed conflict who could be properly detained under the laws and customs of war. But the german saboteurs were tried before a military. The volumes distinguished contributors analyze the crucial questions these cases raise about the balance between national security and civil liberties in wartime, discuss critical separation of powers issues, and call upon the courts, the political branches, and the country to reexamine the complicated connections between the constitution and international law. Ex parte milligan was a landmark case that became the precedent for all future cases regarding limitations on the revocation of a citizens rights in times of war or martial law. A summary and case brief of ex parte quirin, 317 u.
573 380 410 95 1002 1 1411 790 702 222 76 1434 1636 1066 1171 236 26 100 1526 713 562 1086 623 1195 1162 1242 1155 1097 1160 1067 85